Child funds compared: ICICI leads with 14%+ 5-year CAGR, SBI trails with 12%; what should you choose

view original post

Parents plan for their children’s future with a mix of love, discipline, and long-term financial thinking. Whether through fixed deposits or systematic investment plans in mutual funds, each rupee set aside is meant to one day open doors—be it for education, personal growth, or financial security. With Children’s Day having passed just last week, conversations around future planning for young ones have surged, bringing Children’s Mutual Funds into fresh focus.

Advertisement

Related Articles

These specialised funds offer a structured, market-linked path to build wealth over the long term. In a country where education and life-stage expenses continue to rise, such schemes help parents prepare with clarity and purpose. Among the popular choices today are the SBI Magnum Children’s Benefit Fund – Investment Plan and the ICICI Prudential Children’s Fund—two solutions-oriented schemes designed to support child-centric financial goals. Here is a detailed comparison of the two.

SBI Magnum Children’s Benefit Fund

Launched on September 29, 2020, in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, the SBI Magnum Children’s Benefit Fund – Investment Plan has completed five years and quickly gained attention for its impressive performance. The fund has delivered 35% compounded annualised returns since inception, significantly outperforming its benchmark and generating buzz across social media.

Advertisement

The scheme aims to build long-term wealth for children by maintaining a predominantly equity-driven portfolio. As per the October 2025 factsheet, the fund invests across sectors and market caps—large, mid, and small-cap stocks—while also selectively allocating to debt, money markets, REITs/InVITs and gold ETFs.

The equity portion is managed by R. Srinivasan, a veteran in active equity management, while the debt allocation is overseen by Lokesh Mallya. As of October 31, 2025, the fund’s portfolio carries a heavy small-cap tilt of nearly 49%, alongside a sizeable 18% in cash.

Performance across all time periods has been strong. The direct plan delivered 35.22% annualised returns over five years, comfortably beating the CRISIL Hybrid 35+65 – Aggressive Index. The scheme is available only in the name of a minor through a guardian, with minimum investments starting at Rs 5,000 for lump sums or Rs 500–Rs 1,000 for SIPs.

Advertisement

Notably, the fund differs from SBI’s Children’s Benefit Fund – Savings Plan, which leans toward debt. The Investment Plan is structurally aggressive, targeting higher growth by taking higher equity risk.

ICICI Prudential Children’s Fund

The ICICI Prudential Children’s Fund is one of the oldest and most consistent performers in the category. It features a mandatory lock-in of five years or until the child turns 18, encouraging investors to stay focused on long-term goals. The fund takes a diversified approach, combining equity and debt while maintaining flexibility to take select off-benchmark calls.
Its long-term performance has been remarkable. A Rs 10 lakh lump sum investment made in August 2001 would have grown to Rs 3.3 crore by October 31, 2025, translating into 15.58% annual returns, far ahead of the benchmark’s Rs 2.12 crore. SIPs have also delivered strongly: a Rs 10,000 monthly SIP since inception is now worth Rs 2.2 crore, compared to a total investment of Rs 29 lakh.

The fund has beaten its benchmark across one-, three-, and five-year periods. Simulations show that starting early offers massive advantages, as parents who begin investing at birth need to commit significantly lower monthly amounts to reach goals such as RS 50 lakh by age 18.

Advertisement

Head-to-head comparison

While both funds serve the same purpose, they adopt fundamentally different philosophies.
Performance:

ICICI Prudential leads across most timeframes with 14%+ five-year CAGR, versus SBI’s ~12% five-year CAGR since launch. ICICI also outperforms SBI on one- and three-year returns.

Risk profile: SBI Magnum carries significantly higher risk due to a deep small-cap allocation. ICICI maintains a more balanced equity mix and can allocate up to 35% to debt.

Structure: ICICI’s mandatory lock-in enforces discipline. SBI has no lock-in but imposes a 3% exit load within one year.

                     SBI Magnum Children’s Benefit Fund –     ICICI Prudential
                     Investment Plan                                         Children’s Fund
  ———— —————————————- ————————
  Fund Type    Open-ended, solutions-oriented           Open-ended children’s
               children’s fund                                               fund with mandatory
                                                      

Advertisement

  Lock-in      No mandatory lock-in; 3% exit load       5 years or until child
  Period       within 1 year                            turns 18

  Minimum      Rs 5,000 lump sum; Rs 500 SIP                Rs 5,000 lump sum;
  Investment                                                                       Rs 500–Rs 1,000 SIP

  1-Month      1.84%                                    3.07%
  Return                                                

  6-Month      Not available                            Not available
  Return                                                

  1-Year       6.36%                                    18.04%
  Return                                                

Advertisement

  3-Year       ~9% CAGR                                 11.88% CAGR
  Return                                                

  5-Year       ~12.2% CAGR                              14.21% CAGR
  Return                                                

  Equity       ~82%                                     65–100%
  Allocation                                            

  Debt         ~0.2%                                    0–35%
  Allocation                                            

  Cash         ~18%                                     Varies
  Allocation                                            

  Market Cap   Large 7.55%, Mid 31.55%, Small 39.49%    Diversified
  Mix                                                                                      large/mid/small

  Style        Aggressive, small-cap heavy              Balanced, flexible

  Best For     High-risk investors                      Long-term, stability-focused
                                                        
 

Who should invest?

ICICI Prudential suits parents seeking stability and structured long-term compounding.
SBI Magnum is better suited for those willing to take higher risks for potentially higher returns.
Both funds, in their own ways, help parents transform today’s savings into tomorrow’s opportunities—one disciplined, one aggressive, but both built for your child’s future.

Disclaimer: Business Today provides market and personal news for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. All mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Readers are encouraged to consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.