CEO Elon Musk has made it clear that Tesla’s future won’t be defined by cars alone. The company wants to become a dominant force in autonomous transportation and mass-produced robotics, with Musk floating the idea of producing up to one million Optimus robots annually by the end of the decade.
The ambition is enormous. So is the bill, but what about the stock?
Key Points
-
Spending is soaring as Tesla pours billions into autonomy and robotics before meaningful returns appear.
-
EV profits are weakening, with demand cooling after incentives expired and margins under pressure.
-
The valuation assumes perfection, leaving little room for execution mistakes.
Costs are rising before the payoff is visible
Tesla’s operating expenses jumped roughly 50% year over year in the most recent quarter, while research and development spending soared even faster. Management specifically cited AI initiatives, robotics, and autonomy as key drivers of higher costs, not incremental improvements to the car lineup.
Musk said earlier this year that Tesla’s robotaxi service would reach half the U.S. by year-end. We’re now at that point, and the service remains limited to a small number of tightly controlled markets.
None of this means autonomy or robotics won’t work. It does mean Tesla is pouring billions into projects that may take many years, and possibly regulatory breakthroughs, before they generate meaningful revenue. That’s a tough ask when the core business is under pressure.
The EV engine is sputtering
It’s tempting to think of Tesla as a futuristic AI company, but today it still makes the overwhelming majority of its money selling cars. And that business is losing momentum.
Tesla’s net income fell sharply year over year in the latest quarter, even as revenue held up temporarily thanks to customers rushing to buy before U.S. EV tax credits expired. That pull-forward effect masked a bigger problem.
Once incentives rolled off, monthly vehicle sales dropped to levels Tesla hasn’t seen in years. This isn’t just a Tesla issue, it’s an industry-wide signal that EV demand is far more price-sensitive than many expected. Higher interest rates, lingering inflation, and rising insurance costs have made EV ownership less attractive for mainstream buyers.
What most investors overlook is how thin Tesla’s automotive margins have become. Price cuts kept volumes moving, but they also reduced the cash Tesla can internally generate to fund its autonomy and robotics ambitions. In other words, Tesla is trying to finance moonshots at the same time its primary profit engine is slowing.
The valuation leaves no room for mistakes
Even if you believe Tesla will eventually crack autonomy and robotics, the stock price assumes a near-perfect execution path.
At current levels, Tesla trades at a price-to-earnings multiple that’s several times higher than the broader technology sector. That kind of valuation only works when profits are accelerating, not shrinking.
The market is already valuing Tesla as if it will become a leader in autonomous ride-hailing and robotics, industries that don’t yet exist at scale and face heavy regulatory and technical hurdles. Investors are paying today for earnings that may not materialize for years, if ever.
That’s a dangerous setup during a period when expenses are climbing, profits are falling, and competition in EVs is intensifying.
The bottom line
Tesla remains one of the most innovative companies on the planet, and its long-term vision is undeniably compelling. But great companies don’t always make great stocks, especially when expectations get ahead of fundamentals.
Right now, Tesla is asking investors to fund a costly transition while its core business weakens and its valuation leaves little margin for error. Until EV demand stabilizes and the company shows clearer progress toward profitable autonomy or robotics, patience looks like the smarter move.
For now, Tesla stock feels less like a bargain on future innovation, and more like a high-stakes bet with very little room to miss.